What to do after Form I-751 denial and court appearance preparation?

Question

I received a letter from the immigration office stating that my Form I-751 was denied, and my stay in the United States was terminated as of June 2023. There was no specific reason given for the denial. It's my first time facing such an issue, and I'm unsure about what steps to take next. How can I prepare for the upcoming court appearance?

James L. Arrasmith · Answer

I understand you're going through a difficult situation with your I-751 denial. This is undoubtedly stressful, but there are clear steps you can take now. 
 
When your Form I-751 is denied, you cannot directly appeal this decision. Instead, the denial typically comes with a Notice to Appear (NTA) in immigration court for removal proceedings. This court appearance is actually your opportunity to defend your case and show why you should be granted permanent residence despite the initial denial. 
 
To prepare for your court appearance, immediately consult with an immigration attorney who can review why your petition was denied and help gather the necessary evidence. Your attorney will prepare documents and affidavits to support your case and represent you before the judge. Remember that in court, you'll face government attorneys advocating for your removal, so having proper legal representation is crucial. 
 
While waiting for your court date, collect additional documentation that proves your eligibility for permanent residence. This might include mortgage or lease contracts showing joint residence, financial records demonstrating shared responsibilities, insurance policies, utility bills with the same address, joint tax returns, and birth certificates of any children. The immigration judge will take a fresh look at your case, allowing you to present new evidence that addresses the concerns that led to the denial.

Q: What to do after Form I-751 denial and court appearance preparation?